By Elizabeth J. Allan, Ph.D.

Note: This commentary expands on a response to Kate Manne’s October 20 New York Times guest essay, exploring the connections between hazing, group culture, and sexual violence.

In her recent New York Times guest essay, Kate Manne examines how fraternity culture and group dynamics can foster misogyny and contribute to sexual violence. More recently, Amanda Doyle explored related concerns in an episode of the We Can Do Hard Things podcast, examining how fraternity hazing can normalize humiliation, coercion, secrecy, and violence.

A question that has been at the forefront of my work as a researcher who studies hazing and its prevention is this: beyond the immediate harm hazing inflicts on those who experience it, how might hazing shape group cultures in ways that enable other forms of interpersonal violence? 

This question matters because it shapes how researchers examine hazing and how educators approach its prevention. That is, is hazing a result of “bad apples” or the “barrel the apples are in”?

It also matters because hazing is not confined to fraternities. It occurs across a wide range of student organizations, athletic teams, and other groups.

These groups are living-learning laboratories where students practice leadership, build group membership, and learn what it means to contribute to something greater than themselves. This learning can carry through in the attitudes and skills an individual brings after graduation to their workplaces, families, and communities. 

Although hazing is often associated with fraternities, it occurs across a wide range of student groups, including athletic teams, clubs, and other organizations. In our original National Study of Student Hazing, we found that three in four fraternity and sorority members had experienced hazing.

Hazing takes many forms, ranging from seemingly innocuous “traditions” to degrading, coercive, and violent acts. Yet across this spectrum, a common thread is the exercise of power and control.

This is one reason the relationship between hazing and sexual violence deserves closer examination.

Hazing as a Process of Socialization

I began examining hazing through a gender lens and observing its parallels with sexual violence after my training as a sexual assault victim advocate and prevention educator in the 1990s. Later, as an early-career scholar, I wrote about some of these connections in a book chapter entitled, Gender and hazing: Analyzing the obvious, published in an edited collection compiled by author and journalist, Hank Nuwer back in 2003.

That writing was informed by my experience as a practitioner in the field and also through the work of scholars like anthropologist Peggy Reeves Sanday, who authored the book, Fraternity Gang Rape: Sex, Brotherhood, and Privilege on Campus, first published in 1990, detailing research on the factors contributing to rape culture in these groups. 

We have long known that hazing is more than an isolated act of mistreatment. It can function as a process through which new members learn what is expected of them, what behaviors are tolerated, and what they must endure to belong.

When humiliation, coercion, or degradation become accepted features of group membership, they can communicate powerful messages about authority, belonging, and the treatment of others.

New members may learn that those with greater status have the right to exert control over others. They may also learn that challenging harmful behavior carries social consequences, while remaining silent is rewarded with acceptance.

Over time, these dynamics can normalize behaviors and attitudes that extend beyond the hazing itself.

Importantly, these processes are not limited to male-dominated groups. Hazing occurs across gender identities and organizational contexts. However, examining how hazing intersects with gender norms, masculinity, and group power structures is particularly important when considering fraternity culture and sexual violence. 

Where Hazing and Sexual Violence Intersect

The connections between hazing and sexual violence are both direct and indirect.

In some instances, hazing itself involves sexual harassment, forced nudity, sexual humiliation, or sexual assault. These practices make the overlap explicit.

But the relationship can extend further. 

Both hazing and sexual violence can involve the misuse of power, violations of personal boundaries, coercion, and disregard for another person’s autonomy and dignity.

Hazing can also reinforce group norms that discourage intervention, minimize or normalize harm, and protect those who hold power within an organization. These norms contribute to the likelihood that hazing will recur year after year. 

This does not mean that everyone who experiences or participates in hazing will engage in sexual violence. Nor does it mean that hazing necessarily causes sexual violence. Rather, the conditions that allow hazing to persist may also create environments in which other forms of interpersonal violence are tolerated or enabled.

Understanding these shared dynamics opens important opportunities for prevention.

Moving Beyond Siloed Prevention

On many college campuses, hazing prevention and sexual violence prevention have developed as distinct areas of policy, education, and institutional responsibility.

Specialized expertise and interventions are valuable. Yet when colleges and universities address these issues separately, they may overlook the organizational and cultural conditions that contribute to multiple forms of harm.

A more comprehensive approach would examine how group norms, power hierarchies, social pressures, and institutional practices influence student behavior and well-being.

It would also shift attention beyond individual misconduct to the environments in which harmful behaviors occur.

For example, prevention efforts can help student organizations, clubs, and teams examine how they establish belonging, distribute power, respond to harmful conduct, and cultivate accountability. These are relevant questions for preventing hazing, sexual violence, and other forms of interpersonal harm.

Research-informed prevention must address not only the behaviors we seek to prevent, but also the conditions and environments that make those behaviors more likely.

At StopHazing, this perspective informs our Building Healthy Groups and Teams initiative, including the 10 Signs of Healthy & Unhealthy Groups Training and companion resources, which encourage students and organizational leaders to intentionally cultivate positive group dynamics and healthier forms of belonging.

Changing the Culture of Belonging

Many students join fraternities, athletic teams, and other campus organizations seeking connection, friendship, identity, and community. These are meaningful and legitimate aspirations.

But belonging should never require or encourage surrendering one’s dignity, bodily autonomy, or safety.

If we want to prevent sexual violence and other forms of interpersonal harm, we must look closely at how groups socialize their members, establish expectations, and exercise power.

Hazing is an important part of that conversation.

Ultimately, preventing hazing and sexual violence requires more than responding to individual incidents. It requires examining and changing the group cultures that normalize coercion, humiliation, and the misuse or abuse of power.

Preventing hazing is not simply about eliminating harmful initiation or induction practices. It is also about creating group cultures in which belonging is grounded in dignity, care, accountability, and respect for others.

That is a goal that should unite our efforts to prevent hazing, sexual violence, and other forms of interpersonal harm.


Send your questions and feedback to: meredith@stophazing.org